Nick Schommer (duh). Not even a question, I would totally date this guy just to stare at him every day.
Phil Hughes...He just looks so fucking hot on the mound. So many innuendoes...
Brandon Morrow...if I ever become famous, ose five pounds and have money to spend on stylish clothes, he is the first person I am hitting up/stalking.
The laxer dude I've been battling the weather to go out to dinner with
Ryan Gosling (not an athlete but he still counts as someone I'd date over soccer hottie)
Andrew MacDonald (controversial choice but possibly true. There's a backstory here, I swear this isn't as random as it seems.)
Robbie Rogers (um, this might be a possible lie, if it came down to him and SH, but I'd definitely consider RR)
Ryan Kesler (not as hot as SH but still, I'd def take him over SH, if he weren't married)
John Hester (I am the only fan this kid has, seriously.)
Eddie Cahill, The dude who played Jim Craig in the movie Miracle. Again, not a legitimate athlete, but a true story none the less. Now he's on like, CSI or something and he cut his hair, which is tragic, but yeah, this wouldn't even be a question, sorry SH.